Skip to content

Country

NEW: HEART DEFENDER - Love Your Heart. It Will Serve You Well If You Do!

Doctors Don’t Follow Their Own Advice

Doctors are hypocrites? No, you’re kidding me! I don’t believe it!

Well, according to a study it’s true. When choosing their own treatment, doctors often do something different to what they tell their patients. Sometimes, very different.

For example, a doctor would not choose an option he or she knew could be fatal—even though he or she was quite happy to recommend that course to a patient! Doctors, it would seem, would rather be paralyzed or in some way disadvantaged than dead. Fair enough. But why don’t they take the same line with a patient?

All this came to light form a study published in the April 11 issue of the Archives of Internal Medicine.

“It’s a pretty clear message: There’s a discrepancy between what doctors recommend to their patients and to themselves,” said Dr. Timothy Quill, author of an accompanying editorial in the journal.

In the study, Dr. Peter A. Ubel, a physician and behavioral scientist at Duke University ,and his colleagues presented one of two different treatment-decision scenarios to primary care physicians in the United States.

For the first scenario, 242 doctors were told that either they or a patient had just been diagnosed with colon cancer and could choose one of two surgeries. Both options had a cure rate of 80%, but one had a higher death rate and fewer side effects. The other had a lower death rate but patients were more likely to need a colostomy or to have chronic diarrhea, intermittent bowel obstruction or wound infection.

When it came to their own bodies and lives, 37.8% of physicians chose the option with higher mortality over fewer side effects, but only 24.5% thought that patients should choose this course.

The second scenario involved being infected with a fictitious new strain of avian flu. The flu itself had a 10% death rate and would send 30% of patients to the hospital for an average of one week.

The one treatment would halve the rate of adverse events, but would kill 1% of recipients and cause permanent paralysis in 4%.

Of the nearly 700 doctors completing this survey, 62.9% decided that they personally would endure the flu rather than get this treatment. For their patients, however, only about half (48.5%) recommended foregoing treatment in the event of infection.

I would say hypocrisy is fair comment, wouldn’t you?

SOURCE: April 11, 2011 Archives of Internal Medicine

 

The post Doctors Don’t Follow Their Own Advice appeared first on Alternative Doctor Dev Site.

Older Post
Newer Post
Close (esc)

Popup

Use this popup to embed a mailing list sign up form. Alternatively use it as a simple call to action with a link to a product or a page.

Age verification

By clicking enter you are verifying that you are old enough to consume alcohol.

Search

Shopping Cart